Do I Need a Lawyer for a Car Accident Settlement?

How badly you were hurt is the biggest factor in whether you need a lawyer after a car accident. If you weren’t injured or injuries were minor, or you were checked out once and no treatment followed, you may be able to settle a car accident claim yourself.

Settlements You May Be Able to Handle Yourself

Handling it yourself may be a reasonable call when all of the following are true:

  • You weren’t injured, injuries were minor, or you were checked out once and no treatment followed.
  • The other driver caused the crash and their insurance company has accepted responsibility.
  • You can total any medical bills and lost pay from documents you already have.
  • Nobody has claimed a right to repayment out of your settlement.
  • You missed little or no work.

On a minor claim, gather your itemized bills and proof of lost pay, send the insurance company a written demand, and read the release closely before you sign.

Signs You Need a Lawyer for Your Settlement

You can check each of the following yourself, and any one of them is reason to have an offer reviewed before you sign.

The Offer Arrived While You Were Still Treating

An adjuster generally builds an offer from bills already incurred, so a number that arrives while you are still going to appointments reflects a partial course of care. The Texas Department of Insurance advises talking to your doctor about future medical treatment before you sign a release (TDI auto insurance guide), and that conversation is what tells you whether the case is finished.

Your Injury Is Serious

An initial offer is typically priced on what the records showed at the time, and a serious injury can take weeks to document. Any of the following suggests your case is past what a quick number covers:

  • An X-ray, MRI, or CT scan found a fracture, disc injury, or nerve damage.
  • A doctor recommended injections or surgery.
  • You have a referral to a specialist you have not used yet.

A serious injury keeps costing you after the case closes, and a number set before the full extent was known is unlikely to account for that.

The Offer Doesn’t Go Beyond the Total of Your Bills

Add up your medical bills and lost pay. If the offer is roughly that number, it covers your costs and nothing more.

Texas law treats the rest of what you lost as a separate category (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.001):

  • Physical pain
  • Mental anguish
  • Disfigurement
  • Physical impairment
  • Loss of enjoyment of life

None of that appears on a bill, so none of it is built into an offer that matches your expenses.

You Have Not Gone Back to Your Old Hours or Duties

Going back to work does not always mean the loss is over. If you are on reduced hours, or cannot return to the same job, you will keep earning less after the settlement is signed. Lost future income counts separately from the paychecks you already missed.

The Insurance Company Says You Were Partly at Fault

An insurance company that blames you for part of the crash has a reason to pay you less, and the percentage it puts on you may come from the police report or anything you said in a recorded statement. A fault percentage from an insurance company isn’t final, and photographs, witnesses or other evidence can counter their argument. Texas’ proportionate responsibility statute ends recovery if your share of the blame is greater than 50 percent (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.001), and a smaller share reduces what you collect, so the percentage you are ultimately assigned decides how much of the case gets paid.

Your Symptoms Are Being Blamed on an Old Injury

A bad back, a prior surgery, or an old shoulder problem gives an insurance company a reason to discount your claim, usually by calling your symptoms age-related degeneration or something left over from before the crash.

Blaming your history is an argument, not a finding. Countering it takes your treating doctor comparing your condition before the crash with your condition after, and the records to support the comparison.

Your Bills Are Approaching the Other Driver’s Limits

Texas requires only $30,000 of injury coverage per person (TDI auto insurance guide), so a single hospital stay can exceed everything the at-fault policy will pay. An offer at the limits is not the same as an offer that covers your losses. Coverage can exist beyond that policy, including an employer’s policy on the vehicle, a second party who shares fault, or the underinsured motorist coverage you carry yourself.

A case can need a lawyer for reasons that are not on this list. In most cases the size of your loss decides whether hiring one helps. A small loss stays small no matter who negotiates it, and the more your losses exceed what an offer covers, the more there is for a lawyer to recover.

Amounts That Come Out of the Settlement Either Way

Handling the settlement yourself may avoid a contingency fee that a lawyer would charge, but it does not mean the whole amount of the settlement stays with you. More than one party can claim repayment out of settlement money:

  • Medicare, which can recover from anyone who received settlement money, including you (42 CFR 411.24).
  • An employer health plan governed by ERISA, whose rights attach to the settlement money itself (Montanile v. Board of Trustees, 577 U.S. 136).
  • A hospital, where Texas allows a lien against settlement proceeds if the hospital admitted you within 72 hours of the crash (Tex. Prop. Code ch. 55).
  • Your own personal injury protection or medical payments carrier, depending on your policy.

Medicare does not always take back the full amount. If you hired a lawyer to pursue a disputed claim, Medicare reduces what it collects to cover a share of the cost (42 CFR 411.37). Part of the fee comes back to you that way.

Sample Settlement Amounts: With a Lawyer and Without One

Contingency Fee and Case Costs

Your fee agreement has to be in writing and has to state how the fee gets determined, including a percentage for each outcome if settlement, trial and appeal carry different rates, along with whether expenses come off before or after the fee is calculated (Texas Disciplinary Rule 1.04(d)). Case costs are billed separately from the fee and cover items like medical records retrieval and expert review. When the case ends, your lawyer owes you a written statement showing the outcome and how your share was calculated.

Two Sample Cases Side by Side

Everything below is invented for illustration. No one can predict what a case settles for, and the increases shown are assumptions rather than typical results. Fee percentages vary by agreement, case costs vary by case, and two crashes with similar injuries can settle for very different amounts. Nothing here describes any actual case or predicts what yours would bring.

Sample A, moderate injury:

 Without a lawyerWith a lawyer
Settlement$40,000$60,000 (assumed)
Attorney fee at 35% (estimate)$0$21,000
Case costs (estimate)$0$3,000
Before repayment$40,000$36,000

Sample B, serious injury with surgery:

 Without a lawyerWith a lawyer
Settlement$75,000$225,000 (assumed)
Attorney fee at 35% (estimate)$0$78,750
Case costs (estimate)$0$20,000
Before repayment$75,000$126,250

Figures above are illustrative and percentages vary by agreement. Repayment to Medicare, a health plan or a hospital comes out of both columns. The fee question tends to decide small cases, and it makes less difference as the medical bills get larger.

Before You Sign Anything

A lawyer usually makes the most difference on a serious injury, where the amounts are larger and more of the case is open to argument. If that sounds like your situation, have someone look at the offer before you sign.

If your injury was minor and required little or no medical attention, you may already have your answer. If your injury was serious take advantage of a free consultation with Loewy Law Firm by calling (512) 280-0800 or sending us a text message at (512) 779-3547.

References and Additional Reading

The content on this website is for general informational purposes and should not be considered legal advice. Laws change, and case outcomes depend on specific facts. Viewing this material does not establish an attorney-client relationship. For legal guidance on your specific situation, consult a qualified attorney.